Gina Colvin disciplinary council

[Heber13]

I think it debunks the sometimes suggested accusations that church leaders seek out to discipline alternate voices in the church. She mentioned “kindness” … and it is good it is newsworthy to note this as well as the times there is lack of kindness.

Her leaders may not agree with her or even approve…but if there is no threat, there doesn’t need to be action taken. There is a place in church for alternative voices and ideas.

[nibbler]

Heber13 wrote:

There is a place in church for alternative voices and ideas.

*But you may or may not live inside the geographical boundaries that allow you to be a member of that place.

or

**Yeah, and some members refer to that place as “outside.”

[IT_Veteran]

Heber13 wrote:

I think it debunks the sometimes suggested accusations that church leaders seek out to discipline alternate voices in the church. She mentioned “kindness” … and it is good it is newsworthy to note this as well as the times there is lack of kindness.

Her leaders may not agree with her or even approve…but if there is no threat, there doesn’t need to be action taken. There is a place in church for alternative voices and ideas.

Sort of…

Perhaps they didn’t prescribe an outcome in her case, but she did talk about the times her SP would let her know that he received a notice from Salt Lake about something she said.

[Heber13]

IT_Veteran wrote:

Heber13 wrote:

I think it debunks the sometimes suggested accusations that church leaders seek out to discipline alternate voices in the church. She mentioned “kindness” … and it is good it is newsworthy to note this as well as the times there is lack of kindness.

Her leaders may not agree with her or even approve…but if there is no threat, there doesn’t need to be action taken. There is a place in church for alternative voices and ideas.

Sort of…

Perhaps they didn’t prescribe an outcome in her case, but she did talk about the times her SP would let her know that he received a notice from Salt Lake about something she said.

What does that mean to you? Is that a bad thing?

[IT_Veteran]

Heber13 wrote:

IT_Veteran wrote:

Heber13 wrote:

I think it debunks the sometimes suggested accusations that church leaders seek out to discipline alternate voices in the church. She mentioned “kindness” … and it is good it is newsworthy to note this as well as the times there is lack of kindness.

Her leaders may not agree with her or even approve…but if there is no threat, there doesn’t need to be action taken. There is a place in church for alternative voices and ideas.

Sort of…

Perhaps they didn’t prescribe an outcome in her case, but she did talk about the times her SP would let her know that he received a notice from Salt Lake about something she said.

What does that mean to you? Is that a bad thing?

I don’t think it’s good or bad on its own, but it does show that Salt Lake is both aware of her and communicating with her SP. I don’t think there’s enough evidence to say definitively that Salt Lake was pushing for discipline, but I think that it suggests there is some evidence of that.

[Heber13]

IT_Veteran wrote:

it does show that Salt Lake is both aware of her and communicating with her SP. I don’t think there’s enough evidence to say definitively that Salt Lake was pushing for discipline, but I think that it suggests there is some evidence of that.

I’d agree with that.

[Author]

Posts